When considering the challenges facing scientific publishing, Acer VanWallendael suggests that journals should produce audio versions of the papers they publish. Like…
Preregistration at PLOS Biology and Call for COVID-19, SARS-CoV-2 Research
Preregistered Research Articles, while not a new offering at PLOS Biology, offer authors additional guarantee of our commitment to emphasize the importance of the research question in the manuscript evaluation process. This is an important part of our new vision for the journal, and a timely one as it has given us a framework to join a rapid review network and joint call for Registered Reports related to COVID-19 study protocols organized by one of our Editorial Board Members, Chris Chambers. In addition, this article type may offer an opportunity to researchers during the global lab lockdown to begin plans for research projects that can be started once the labs are fully up and running again, knowing that the results will be published.
Call for Papers – Zoonotic Pathogen Emergence
We believe preregistration is a valuable option for researchers in the life sciences, especially now. Preregistration provides a clear way forward for new studies, to strengthen scientific rigor, increase likelihood of reproducibility, and guarantee a venue for publication of the final results before scientific investigation even begins.
To address the current pandemic, and to mitigate future risk, PLOS Biology has expanded the scope of the joint call for papers to include not only directly SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19-related research, but any study relevant to the emergence and outbreak of zoonotic pathogens.
This initiative provides a path for researchers to engage in preregistration at a critical time, and PLOS Biology will support authors with fast-tracked peer review of research specifically related to COVID-19. Our aim is to complete initial Stage 1 peer review within 7 days of receiving the submission, so that researchers can proceed with these urgent investigations as quickly as possible. We will also waive the Article Processing Charge for all accepted Stage 1 Protocols in emerging zoonotic pathogens submitted within the first three months, regardless of when the final article is completed and published.
If you’re interested in submitting your Zoonotic Pathogen preregistered research, click here. For more information about preregistration, and what this means for all PLOS Biology authors, please read on below.
What is preregistration?
Preregistered research articles at PLOS Biology follow our same unique, rigorous editorial process as regular research articles with one exception: there are two stages of review. Authors first submit a manuscript describing your research question, rationale, study design, and proposed methodology for data collection and analysis which will be evaluated by one of our professional editors. If it seems likely that the proposed work will meet our publication criteria, they will consult with an Academic Editor to assess the importance of the research question. Peer reviewers will be invited at each stage to ensure that the study design and methodological approach are sound.
Authors who receive an in-principle acceptance at this stage and can then go out–armed with the best study design possible–to begin their investigation with the confidence that PLOS Biology will publish all of the results, regardless of the outcomes.
After the study is complete, authors will add results and discussion sections to their protocol to create a single, fully integrated article. Peer reviewers at this stage will focus on adherence to the approved protocol, the appropriateness of any deviations, and the accuracy of the conclusions.
What are the benefits of preregistration?
Additional security against publication bias and a strong foundation for reproducibility
PLOS Biology is interested in publishing the best research in the biological sciences that meets our publication criteria, even when that means disproving a theory rather than confirming it. Our new scope puts more emphasis on the research question and creates space for researchers to report different kinds of results than a highly-selective publisher would normally accept. Preregistration just takes this one step further.
Preregistered research articles provide a framework for improving and demonstrating scientific rigor in publications. With expert editors and peer reviewers evaluating the approach before investigation begins, we can ensure that researchers receive relevant advice to craft the best study design possible. By basing the second stage of peer review upon the adherence to this protocol, researchers are able to demonstrate the credibility of their results while ensuring that their work provides enough context to remain replicable over the long term.
With these two key pieces, preregistration frees authors to report negative and null results — even in a highly selective journal– adding to a more robust foundation of knowledge for future researchers to build upon.
Guaranteed publication for authors
We know how difficult it is as a researcher to find the right journal for your work. Combined with the pressure from institutions and funders to be published in a handful of highly selective journals, it can take time to receive an acceptance and share your research with the world. As Chief Science Officer Veronique Kiermer discussed in an earlier post , some journal decisions may seem arbitrary or based on strong headlines rather than scientific quality. Shopping an article around to multiple journals may also slow down the time to publication.
Preregistering your study guards against this by providing early review and assessment before the work even begins. Not only does this result in more rigorously conducted studies, but it gives researchers a clear path to publication. So long as the completed study follows the approved approach or any deviations are deemed justified by reviewers, authors are guaranteed publication in PLOS Biology for their final work.
To build a strong foundation for outcome-neutral assessment and reproducibility, we’ll need increased transparency at each stage of the research and publication process. Preregistration takes us part of the way there but may not be the right option for every research article. In next week’s post, we’ll talk more about the inspiration for two additional article types that help showcase each stage of research.
Can I submit a review article on COVID-19 during pre-registration?
This is a brilliant idea for the scientific community especially for young researchers who come to the frontline. This is the lovely journal in the science world!!!!
There is also the opportunity to preregister studies involving animal experiments in the Animal Study Registry (PLoS Biol. 2019 Oct 15;17(10):e3000463. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.3000463)
The Animal Study Registry (www.animalstudyregistry.org) is a free online platform provided by the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) and is available for all researchers around the world.
The full content of the study will be visible when the embargo period expired which can be set for a maximum of 5 years. Preregistered studies recieve a DOI. As a reference this can be send together with a copy of the study to any journal.
I am interested in planning and submitting our work on Plasmodium knowlesi emergence in India as pre-registered research. However it is not clear to me how much time will be provided, once the study design/ protocol is accepted, to be able to submit a final article?
The coronavirus, also call COVID-19 has been officially declared as pandemic, and the world has now to manage it as different level as a major public health, from a politic aspect to manage this pandemic disease, but at the low of the scale, to an individual aspect. The goal of our overview paper is to focus on how individual people could optimize their heath, particularly the immune system to reduce the risk of respiratory track infection through a strategy of daily micronutrition strategy.
This paper presents the results of about 85 articles in order to explain the impact of Vitamin D, Zinc, and vitamin C on the immune system and the regulation of the storm of cytokines. The cross statistics of the person at risk reveal a strong link between these 3 nutrients deficiency (Obesity, Diabet, elderly) and the increase of the mortality rate. Based on this theoretical and statistical background, advices could be given in order to lower this risk.
Waiting your response
University Paris Saclay
I am willing to submit a review article entitled ” COVID-19: Immunobiology, Cytokine Dysregulation, and Therapeutic Targets” in your esteemed journal.
I can send you the abstract before submission for your approval.
Please let me know if this is appropriate for the journal.
I am Dr. S M Rashed Ul Islam, Assistant Professor, working at the Department of Virology and COVID-19 Laboratory at Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib Medical University (BSMMU) from Bangladesh. Thanks for your initiative for this page for encouragements in this Research field during this COVID-19 era. We have got a small fund on the research project on microRNA study in relationship with SARS-CoV-2 infection in Blood/Respiratory specimens. I would like to engage myself with Plos Biology for guidance and advanced advice, so that, I can enrich this study using the available resources in our low settings.
Thanking you and wisihg you all to be safe and healthy.
We have a case report of MIS-C related to covid19 in 13 years old girl with novel presentation
Can we submit the case in your journal?